Drop or improve the funced behavior

[dag]

Drop or improve the funced behavior

[netmute]

I second this. When opening vim I expect to be in command mode, everything else is confusing.

[dag]

@netmute Let me know if the new behavior is also annoying.

What bugs me is that fish's funced for a new function adds an empty line, so if you just hit o to start inserting the function body the empty line is kept. There's also no way for vim-fish to reliably detect if you're funcediting a new function or an existing one, so if we do anything it needs to work in both cases.

An alternative to the new behavior in vim-fish could be to scan the whole file to detect if it looks like a new function (ie. has no function body) and then delete that empty line. This would be more work though, and arguably more magical (even if perhaps less surprising). Thoughts?

[netmute]

Less magic is better in my opinion. I can always just do an S on the empty line, doesn't really bother me.

[dag]

And the new behavior of placing the cursor on that line, useful or annoying? It's not a big win over jS, admittedly, but I think the latter requires more mental effort if nothing else.

[netmute]

It stays out of my way, so it's fine :)