"Sign in with Google temporarily disabled for this app"

[scotthansonde]

"Sign in with Google temporarily disabled for this app"

[DSchau]

I'm going to re-open this... been pinged a few times that it's not working, so it'd be nice to just fix it.

[sgrove]

Yeah, the issue here is that Google is very protective of Gmail access, and they want to review any apps before they have a chance to cause too much public damage. The middle-ground they've found is that you can have N people sign into your app before it's shut down for anyone except for you (the author of the Google app).

The reason you can use the OneGraph app is that it's be reviewed as a developer tool, and doesn't ask for "write" (send, really) permissions, so the review is softer. We've seen some pretty intense requests for redesigns/more informative verbiage, and fewer permissions on some of the apps using Gmail.

If you end up publishing a real GatsbyMail for others to use, you'd want to create an OAuth client in Google, add the client id/secret in the OneGraph app dashboard, and they have your app reviewed well before launching publicly.

[DSchau]

Thanks for weighing in @sgrove!

Since this is more of less for demo purposes (see the "Don't use this for anything real" in the live app, ha) I'm going to close this out!

If you're interested in using any of this for a real app @papascott definitely check out some of the advice above to move past some of these technical hurdles/challenges.

[dnafication]

Hi @DSchau, Will this issue resove if the developer created a new account in onegraph and used his/her appId in .env file ('GATSBY_OG_APP_ID')?

[DSchau]

@dnafication sorry for the delay--but yes that should work!

[myisaak]

Just to make peoples lives a bit easier I updated the readme to avoid this issue. In my case, I needed to create a onegraph account since my Google account requires permission which can only be accepted by a self-created account.

[DSchau]

@myisaak think that should do the trick, for now at least.

Longer term--I need to get off my laurels and actually make this a real app with Google OAuth authentication as @sgrove mentioned earlier.

(So once more--let's keep this open!)

[erdahuja]

Even for onegraph account it gave the same message, "Sign in with google is disabled". I also tried t connect oneGraph account with google, same message.

[myisaak]

Look at https://developers.google.com/identity/protocols/oauth2/javascript-implicit-flow