.formatMessage is not working when provided messages has object with `type: 1`

[duc-gp]

.formatMessage is not working when provided messages has object with `type: 1`

[longlho]

I'm confused. Are you trying to specify messages in ICU AST form?
type: 1 is argument, your value is just a string

[duc-gp]

I'm confused. Are you trying to specify messages in ICU AST form? type: 1 is argument, your value is just a string

What is this ICU AST form you are talking about? Can you please provide a documentation? Type 0 is working, type 1 not. You can see it in my codepen example

[longlho]

https://formatjs.io/docs/react-intl/components#intlprovider

you wanna pass in Record<string, string> to messages in your Provider

[duc-gp]

https://formatjs.io/docs/react-intl/components#intlprovider

you wanna pass in Record<string, string> to messages in your Provider

Thank you but I mean the documentation for this type: 0 and type: 1 thing. Have you checked my codesandbox? If not, please see my codesandbox. There you can see that type: 0 is working but type: 1 is not.

Why is that? Can you provide a documentation for that?

[longlho]

The payload form you're passing in is a list of MessageFormatElement chunks. Type 0 is a literal chunk. Type 1 is a argument chunks but those are implementation details.
You should pass in strings instead of passing in map of string to array. Where in the documentation do you get that param shape?

[duc-gp]

The payload form you're passing in is a list of MessageFormatElement chunks. Type 0 is a literal chunk. Type 1 is a argument chunks but those are implementation details. You should pass in strings instead of passing in map of string to array. Where in the documentation do you get that param shape?

Okay I see.. so this is officially not recommended and never was or is that some kind of legacy thing how it was used to be used?

I'm working on legacy code and all the translation were like that passing arrays of objects with that type and value keys :(

[longlho]

Those have never been supported AFAIK. The array form is our internal AST format which isn't technically public.

[duc-gp]

Ok, then nevermind and thanka a lot for the clarification. This issue can be closed then