About training with DN-Deformable-DETR-R50

[idea-research]

About training with DN-Deformable-DETR-R50

[FengLi-ust]

Yes, it is possible. In our original DN-DETR repo, DN-Deformable-DETR can get 46.1 in 12 epochs.
One reason for your better performance is that training with small batchsize will accelerate convergence in the early stage, I have verified this before.
In addition, detrex implementation is better than our original DN-DETR repo. (:

[Mr-Bigworth]

Yes, it is possible. In our original DN-DETR repo, DN-Deformable-DETR can get 46.1 in 12 epochs. One reason for your better performance is that training with small batchsize will accelerate convergence in the early stage, I have verified this before. In addition, detrex implementation is better than our original DN-DETR repo. (:

Thanks, but I wonder why the result of DN-Deformable-DETR in paper[1] is 43.4 and why 'Deformable' can bring so large improvement. DN-Detr-R50 get only 38.5 in paper[2] and I also verified it.

[Mr-Bigworth]

[1] DN-DETR: Accelerate DETR Training by Introducing Query DeNoising
[2] GROUP DETR: FAST DETR TRAINING WITH GROUPWISE ONE-TO-MANY ASSIGNMENT

[FengLi-ust]

The 43.4 result is our initial implementation without deformable attention in the decoder and some other optimizations. Our released model performs better by better combine deformable detr and dn-detr.

DN-Detr-R50 gets only 38.5 because detection models without multi-scale features converge slowly and cannot do well on small objects. Multi-scale features are strong, and deformable attention is also strong to fuse multi-scale features well.

All these make it even stronger.

[Mr-Bigworth]

The 43.4 result is our initial implementation without deformable attention in the decoder and some other optimizations. Our released model performs better by better combine deformable detr and dn-detr.

DN-Detr-R50 gets only 38.5 because detection models without multi-scale features converges slowly and cannot do well on small objects. Multi-scale features are strong, and deformable attention is also strong to fuse multi-scale features well.

All this make it even more stronger.

Thanks very much for your answer!

[hotcore]

man i just wanna know how long you train your model on "dataloader.train.total_batch_size = 4 and train.max_iter = 360000" ? appreciate！！

[Mr-Bigworth]

man i just wanna know how long you train your model on "dataloader.train.total_batch_size = 4 and train.max_iter = 360000" ? appreciate！！

Training DN-Deformable-DETR-R50 (12 epoch) cost me about 55 hours on one Tesla A100

[hotcore]

man i just wanna know how long you train your model on "dataloader.train.total_batch_size = 4 and train.max_iter = 360000" ? appreciate！！

Training DN-Deformable-DETR-R50 (12 epoch) cost me about 55 hours on one Tesla A100

i use one v100 32g,same settings as you,detrex shows more than 4 days🤣
Anyway, thks for your reply!!