How can I use sha3 with OpenSSL in ruby?

[johanns]

How can I use sha3 with OpenSSL in ruby?

[DaHoopster]

Actually I made it work via pure Ruby by subclassing OpenSSL::Digest. The trick is also call super in the constructor. Thanks!

[johanns]

But it looks like Ruby 2.5.1 doesn't work with this library.

Is there an error message you're receiving when trying to use it? What happens if you run the following code from IRB or Pry (assuming your already installed the gem gem install sha3)?

require 'sha3'
SHA3::Digest::SHA224.new()

Please post any error message(s), and operating system information (sample code would be great too).

Any thoughts on how I can combine the two?

I'd love to help, but I'm unsure how you're trying to "combine" them. Please provide more context.

[DaHoopster]

Sorry, pardon the ambiguities, here are the details 😄

I was attempting to do the below:

require 'sha3'
require 'openssl'

p_key = OpenSSL::PKey::EC.new('secp256k1').generate_key
p_key.sign(SHA3::Digest.new(:sha256), 'a_super_secret')

Because sha3 isn't a subclass of OpenSSL::Digest, I got the follow error:

TypeError:
       wrong argument type SHA3::Digest (expected OpenSSL/Digest)

And I am stuck ...

[johanns]

That's helpful, but unfortunately I don't have a solution for your particular use case. I suppose it would be possible to change the base class to OpenSSL::Digest from Digest::Class (which is also the parent class for OpenSSL::Digest), but that doesn't like a good idea because the actual SHA3 implementation isn't part of OpenSSL library.

Assuming that you must use SHA3, you can either fork this project, and change the base class to OpenSSL::Digest (see below), or create a new OpenSSL::Digest subclass that proxies data to SHA3::Digest.

sha3/ext/sha3/digest.c

Line 234 in 2534b73

cSHA3Digest = rb_define_class_under(mSHA3, "Digest", rb_path2class("Digest::Class"));

[DaHoopster]

Thanks @johanns , I will try forking the project

[DaHoopster]

Hmm still no good. It looks like the error message comes from the C extension within ruby's openssl code. I read it on stackoverflow (lost the link) that in order to add a custom digest, a C struct needs to be used as the context, like this line: https://github.com/ruby/openssl/blob/master/ext/openssl/ossl_digest.h#L16

The type error comes from this line: https://github.com/ruby/openssl/blob/fdcda971a26895ea5c5015a90671ee73039d55e8/ext/openssl/ossl.h#L59

I am not good with C tho ...

[katpadi]

Hi @DaHoopster,

How were you able to make it work? Did you actually monkeypatch the SHA3::Digest class? Can you point me to the right direction? Thanks.