Innovation AI cheating, or breaking rules?

[frankk74]

Innovation AI cheating, or breaking rules?

[Watno]

hi :)

[frankk74]

Here is a list from BGG of un-addressed playing bugs:

1. Road Building: If you share, it is mandatory to meld at least one card from your hand, but the interface lets you say "No thanks."
2. Clothing: In one game I played, the AI activated Clothing on turn 1 as its first action, scored a one, and immediately got the Monument achievement.
3. Translation: AI activates repeatedly to no effect.
4. Agriculture: AI activates with no cards in hand.

from other website:

5. Invention claims World achievement instead Wonder achievement.
6. Implementations of Reformation, Construction, Compass, Road Building are wrong.
7. Official FAQ: If you choose to tuck with this card, you must try and tuck a number of cards equal to half the number of [Leaf] icons on your board. You cannot choose to tuck less.
8. When I apply first part of Construction's dogma opponent doesn't draw 2.
9. When I apply Compass' dogma AI sometimes doesn't transfer a top card without a [Leaf] from my board to AI's board.

------------------- Above are from BGG. Below are new:

10. [It does] one (random) card of each age is removed from play as they are Age Achievement/Score cards

11. Mathematics dogma2 not working???

12. AI PLAYER is claiming achievements for free on other player's turn?

Player 1 In perform_dogma_effect_by_level() ---Reached end of loop.  Next value = .
In play_game() -----------------------------
In play_game?() -----------------------------
Player 1 In perform_AI_action() picked 0 and 1 ai_mode = 0.
In make_ai_move() ++++++
Player 2 In make_ai_move() called with depth = 0.
Player 2 In make_ai_move() Trying move 0,1 at level 0 (ai_mode = 0)  gss_count = 128.
Player 2 In make_ai_move() Made a real move 0,1 actions_remaining = 1.
Player 1 In achieve() +++trying to click 1.
>>>>>>>>>>>>In can_achieve() +++
>>>>>>>>>>>>Player 2 has claimed the -1- achievement.
Player 1 In perform_AI_action() Made move 0 ai_mode = 0.

[jsparkes]

Should we create issues for these bugs? Probably good not to lose track of them.

…

On Mon, Jun 6, 2022 at 6:33 PM Frank Kannemann ***@***.***> wrote: Here is list from BGG of un-addressed playing bugs: 1 - * Road Building: If you share, it is mandatory to meld at least one card from your hand, but the interface lets you say "No thanks." 2 - * Machinery: If your red cards are already splayed left, the game becomes stuck. 3 - * Clothing: In one game I played, the AI activated Clothing on turn 1 as its first action, scored a 1, and immediately got the Monument achievement. 4 - * Invention: In one game, AI activated Invention and got the World achievement when it should have gotten the Wonder achievement. 5 - * AI bug: AI activates Translation repeatedly to no effect. 6 - * AI bug: AI activates Agriculture with no cards in hand. — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#1 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAAKJB4KOLLSNUWLKSO2WXTVNZ4CRANCNFSM5XXMJI7A> . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

-- Jeff Sparkes ***@***.***

[frankk74]

Will do ,,, wanted them here as a start... sort of a jumbo list that will point to the full issues if they warrant it and we can triage here....also we can peek in the code and verify the above ones…?

[frankk74]

Updating title because you added file logging….thx…

[frankk74]

Over on BGG @Watno reminded me there was further info Jeff mentioned about the AI here: https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/896090/article/10884026#10884026