Controller class name vs file name

[laravel]

Controller class name vs file name

[DPr00f]

I think L4 way is much more cleaner, and allows you to organize your app in a cleaner way, yes in L3 you could do 'auth@login', but you memorize that the first parameter is the Controller, in the L4 version you don't need to memorize anything, you just need to read and identify where is the controller and where is method.
I think L4 approach, to be more meaningful is good, you may write a little bit more of code, but you can read it as it was english.
Maybe they'll change it to L3 Routes, but i really doubt that.

[bencorlett]

Much prefer L4's way of specifying controllers to respond a route. There is no convention anymore (which I'm stoked about) for naming of, well, any class in L4. This leads to huge flexibility.

If you require your app to have this logic, you could create a package and put it up on composer or you could simply edit a couple of files to manipulate the core to behave like you'd want. You could also do something like:

<?php

// in start.php
$app['router'] = $app->share(function($app) { return new MyCustomRouter($app) });

// in MyCustomRouter.php
class MyCustomRouter extends Illuminate\Routing\Router {

    protected function createControllerCallback($attribute)
    {
        list($controllerAlias, $method) = explode('@', $attribute);

        $actualController = ucfirst($controllerAlias).'Controller';

        return parent::createControllerCallback($actualController.'@'.$method);
    }

}

And vòila, you've got your app-specific controller assumptions and logic.

[niallobrien]

I think I forgot to dump-autoload after renaming. Foo.PHP and classname Foo works fine.
However, a note to others, perhaps keeping Controller in the name is better. Yes, generating an URL isn't as clean (FooController@index) however, when you've lots of files open, it's a lot easier to know which tab is your controller! ;)

[robclancy]

In L4 you can actually name things any way you like as it isn't mapped that way, it uses composers autoloader which will map a file path to whatever class is used. So you could name your file snake_case_name.php and then the controller RandomController_Name and it would still work fine.