Web Clipper: Open newly created note opens new window with garbage in Firefox

[bgoodmansf]

Web Clipper: Open newly created note opens new window with garbage in Firefox

[graphit0]

I couldn't reproduce this behaviour

Firefox 124 Nightly
Brave 1.62 Chromium 121
Joplin 2.14.14
Clipper 2.11.2
ubuntu 22.04

• Firefox opens new window with URL: joplin://x-callback-url/openNote?id=588ee103a214443ebd89d1039b26b762
• opening the note from the web clipper opens a new window in Firefox with garbage URL

This URL is external link to clipped note and should open dialogue to run Joplin window with created note

Firefox

Brave (chromium)

Could you be possibly running portable version of Joplin?

[bgoodmansf]

I have tried this on both Windows 10, Windows 11 and Fedora 39 with the same result. I am running the non-portable version of Joplin on Windows. Here is a screenshot after clipping a note on Fedora.

[graphit0]

Could you report what application is assigned to open joplin:// links

In firefox: General -- Applications

[bgoodmansf]

On Fedora 39, my FIrefox settings looks the same as yours (Use Joplin (default).

Note that the note is opened correctly in Joplin. But the window/tab is left open in Firefox. In Chrome, the window/tab goes away.

[graphit0]

So the issue here is the tab not closing or there's no warning that you may close the tab afterwards?
Or there's some other expected behaviour?
Gotta clarify that in expected behaviour of original issue.

[bgoodmansf]

From the user's perspective, they asked to open a note in Joplin. Instead a tab or window opens in the browser.

I don't know if opening a browser window is a required part of the sequence, but it is definitely not what the user expects. It may be that Chrome also opens a browser window, but it gets closed.

I will add more to the expected behavior.

[graphit0]

Okay, I can see that now, thanks. Would be nice to update the title as well 👀

[bgoodmansf]

The title seems correct to me. The problem is that there is window of junk opened in Firefox.

What do you think would be a better description?

[graphit0]

I see. In my view, opening new tab with external x-callback-url is expected behavior. Joplin uses it to communicate with other applications -- for example you can create a desktop shortcut that would open a particular note using this kind of link.

I believe Joplin expects user to interact with such links, so maybe there's a point of making it somehow more intuitive and easy. That said, I believe x-callback-url is not garbage 😅 (not to mention calling it that might be offensive to people who developed it -- who has main knowledge to fix it)

To keep this particular issue focused on functionality (i.e. not to deal with UX -- without a designer, it's difficult to work on such issues) I suggest the following title

Web Clipper: "Open newly created note" doesn't close its tab after redirect in Firefox

[bgoodmansf]

I am certain Joplin does NOT expect the user to interact with the tab because it is deleted when using Chrome.