Missing docName

[mmarkdown]

Missing docName

[miekg]

I've raised this on the xml2rfc-dev list; RFC 7991 says it's removed, but xml2rfc still implements it and IETF now rejects it.

This is in part because the XMLv3 effort is not going too well... For docName you re-used seriesInfo.value?

[miekg]

See https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/xml2rfc-dev/?qdr=d

This is easily fixed, but I'm not sure what the final way of doing this will be and if this would invalidate any XML now generated :/

[miekg]

Per https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/xml2rfc-dev/?qdr=d

I'd like to know the rejection message from the datatracker. There are
any number of possible rejection reasons that have nothing to do with
docName, even if the description in #76 seems to indicate that it's related.

I may be able to fish the rejection reason out if I know the draft name and
submission date. Could you provide that?

I'll check the code to see if the warning should be an error, but would really
like to see the rejection message to understand what's up.

I know need to make code changes for something that is actually not described
anywhere, but seems mandatory.

You can expect that docName will continue to be needed.

[FiloSottile]

The rejection reason was

No docName attribute found in the xml root element

I am pretty sure it's about docName 😄 and simply setting it to seriesInfo.value generated what is now draft-hdevalence-cfrg-ristretto-01.

[miekg]

See #77, can you test? I don't have a I-D laying around (although some test I-D might make sense here)

[miekg]

Should be fixed iwth #77

[dunglas]

Hi, this doesn't look to be fixed.

xml2rfc also wants the docName attribute on the rfc element.
If it helps, you can try with this ID: https://github.com/dunglas/mercure/blob/master/spec/mercure.md

[miekg]

[ Quoting <[email protected]> in "Re: [mmarkdown/mmark] Missing docNa..." ]

Hi, this doesn't look to be fixed. `xml2rfc` also wants the `docName` attribute on the `rfc` element. If it helps, you can try with this ID: https://github.com/dunglas/mercure/blob/master/spec/mercure.md

~~~ % grep docName render/xml2/title.go ~/go/mmark master attrs = append(attrs, `docName="`+d.SeriesInfo.Value+"\"") ~~~ /Miek

…

-- Miek Gieben