CO2 concentration in LUMIP's esm-ssp585-ssp126Lu

[oyvindseland]

CO2 concentration in LUMIP's esm-ssp585-ssp126Lu

[YanchunHe]

@oyvindseland

On NIRD:
/projects/NS9560K/noresm/cases/b.e21.NSSP585frc2.f19_tn14.CMIP6-SSP5-8.5-SSP1-2.6Lu.001/LUMIP

This should be the raw output. But the case directory is unfortunately not archived here!

[JorgSchwinger]

Hi all

from the raw output I figure that this simulation was not set up as emission driven as it should. Therefore, the CO2 output is meaningless (both in cmorized as well as raw data), and this cannot be fixed without setting up the simulation correctly and re-running it. I am not sure whether we have the capacity to do this.

We should retract this simulation from ESGF.

Sorry Tam, we're not able to provide the correct CO2, at least not in the near future. Thanks for making us aware of this issue!

[JorgSchwinger]

I can confirm this observation, the co2 output in esm-ssp585-ssp126Lu seems to be wrong. It is correct in the cmorized esm-ssp585 simulation, so this does not seem to be a comorization problem. I believe this simulation was run by Yanchao Fan, but I have no idea, whether the case directory is still available somewhere. Based on this output, I see the possibility that the simulation set-up was incorrect, so it would be good to check the set-up in the case-directory. Maybe Jerry has more information?

[tjiputra]

This was run by Lei Cai ([email protected]). I contacted him earlier and he told me he has no longer access to Fram and can't check the case. Someone need to reinitiate his access to investigate this further.

[oyvindseland]

Yes, I agree that it is likely to be an error in the set-up, but if we know the adress of the simulation on Nird we can also check the raw output. Can this be checked from any cmorization log ? @YanchunHe

I checked Lei Cai 's directory on the INES project. There are no coupled cases, only land only in that project so it has to be found somewhere else..

[tammasloughran]

Hi folks,

many thanks for tracking down the raw data for this simulation. Is there any way to make the CO2 concentration data from that available to me?

Kind regards,
Tam

[tammasloughran]

Okay I understand

[YanchunHe]

This experiment will be retracted (refer to the above-mentioned issue in the noresm2cmor github repository).