Failing to return to 2D mode on removing headset with VDXR/PimaxXR

[sicsix]

Failing to return to 2D mode on removing headset with VDXR/PimaxXR

[sicsix]

From what I've been able to figure out, but I could be mistaken, it seems like the Oculus XR runtime itself is sending XR_SESSION_STATE_STOPPING and XR_SESSION_STATE_IDLE when it no longer detects it's being worn, but VDXR sends nothing.

[mbucchia]

There is no proper support for "user presence" sensing in OpenXR 1.0. What the Oculus OpenXR runtime does has been a source of debate for a while, and the behavior they implement is not in the OpenXR spec and not guaranteed across all OpenXR implementations. This behavior implemented by Oculus is also a major source of headaches for users (go ask DCS users and how they all have taped their sensor on the headset to go around game/runtime bugs due to it).

VDXR/PimaxXR do not implement this non-standard behavior.

[praydog]

Would a keybind to switch back to desktop mode for these other runtimes be an acceptable workaround?

[sicsix]

Understandable, although it is a useful feature in this particular use case.

Is it possible to detect the HMD worn state through the other runtimes through polling? If so maybe a toggle-able option to switch automatically would be a better UX. Although I'm guessing since user presence sensing is non-standard that's likely a no. So a keybind is likely the only option if that's the case.

[mbucchia]

Is it possible to detect the HMD worn state through the other runtimes through polling

It isn't in OpenXR 1.0. There is an extension in the works for this. Right now the session state events are not implemented the same way across vendors, so you can't make assumption on them.

[sicsix]

In that case a keybind would great for now, will make it playable for all runtimes.

[praydog]

Added in 4f9f362

[sicsix]

Just tested it and works perfectly, thanks for the fix.