gx install <pkg> -- does nothing

[whyrusleeping]

gx install -- does nothing

from gx.

[jbenet]

looks like gx import <pkg> is the thing gx wants me to do.

• other pkg mgrs use gx install <pkg> (see npm)
• at the very least gx install <pkg> should return an error.

[whyrusleeping]

@jbenet right. I had the concepts of 'fetch all dependencies' and 'grab a new dependency' as separate in my mind. Do you think that it should just be install?

Where gx install has the same behaviour that it currently has, and gx install XYZ does what gx import XYZ does now?

[hackergrrl]

(Aside: gx is super cool!)

I'm partial to the way npm separates downloading ("installing") a package and adding a package dependency ("saving"):

npm install X: download X and place it in vendor/ -- don't update package.json
npm install --save X: like the above, but add it as a package dependency
npm install: expands to npm install X Y Z, assuming pkg depends on X, Y, and Z

[whyrusleeping]

@noffle yeah, i think i agree with this.

how about this:
gx install X acts like npm install X, no package.json changes
gx import X acts like npm install --save X, and updates the package.json
gx install --save X can essentially be an alias to gx import
gx install currently expands to gx install X Y Z, just like npm install

[hackergrrl]

@whyrusleeping yes! Brilliant. :)

Just to clarify, I think that both install and import should both still create the named symlink in vendor/ -- agreed?

[whyrusleeping]

@noffle yeah, i want to keep that. Right now, the link is added at the same time its imported, and the linkname is written to the package.json so that the same link is created on further installs.

[whyrusleeping]

this now does a thing, closing