Windowing instead of pagination

[neverfox]

Windowing instead of pagination

[Wildhoney]

Aren't the two paradigms very similar — at least from the perspective of the server-side implementation? Instead of having next and previous, you could scroll, and simply keep loading the additional pages. Use the perPage to limit how many each scroll would yield.

[neverfox]

Hmm, you might be right. I was thinking mainly in terms of the client-side differences. For some reason, I got the impression that each new request to the server altered the whole collection landscape server-side, but I could choose the necessary merging strategy to keep my window populated appropriately (if the scrolling stops mid-way between pages for example, or if I'm pre-fetching the next few). Is that what you're getting at?

[Wildhoney]

Yep — you're right in that it alters the collection landscape, but that's more of a client-side problem.

I suppose taking the user to the top of the page to begin their infinite scroll journey from scratch would be the most logical. That's how most infinite scrolls that I've seen operate, because otherwise where you are on the page post filter/reorder would bear no resemblance to where you were pre filter/reorder — and thus simply confuse the user. There would also be DOM issues (unless you're being clever by not rendering unseen pages), such as if the user had scrolled to page 5001, then repainting all of those pages when reordering would be terribly slow.

As long as you don't reorder and/or apply filters, then each request is predictable.

[neverfox]

I suppose taking the user to the top of the page to begin their infinite scroll journey from scratch would be the most logical.

Right. Filtering when only viewing some of the data screws with one's mental model, but I'm not sure if it's any worse for infinite scrolling than the pagination story, since most of what keeps you from getting disoriented is some kind of feedback about where you are whether it's (page 3 of 10,000) or (records 100-110 of 100,000).

unless you're being clever by not rendering unseen pages

Yes, I am indeed, using react-list.

In any case, I'm going to give it a shot and I can report back about how it went.