Cannot import `(scheme srfi-170)`

[bentxt]

Cannot import `(scheme srfi-170)`

[lassik]

It's kind of obscure, but R7RS section 5.6.1 Library Syntax says:

Libraries whose first identifier is scheme are reserved for use by this report and future versions of this report. Libraries whose first identifier is srfi are reserved for libraries implementing Scheme Requests for Implementation.

This is the (srfi 1) form that all R7RS implementations now use. (Guile was the last holdout, but (import (srfi 1)) now works in Guile 3.0.9.)

[yuriy-chumak]

That's strange...

~/Workspace/ol.git$ sudo make uninstall
rm -rf /usr/bin/ol
rm -rf /usr/bin/olvm
rm -rf /usr/lib/libol.so
rm -rf /usr/lib/ol/repl
rm -rf /usr/lib/ol
rm -rf /usr/include/ol
rm -rf /usr/share/man/man1/ol.1.gz

~/Workspace/ol.git$ sudo make install
# install Ol executable(s) to /usr/bin:
Installing main binary...
install -d /usr/bin
install ol /usr/bin/ol
Installing ol virtual machine binary...
install -d /usr/bin
install vm /usr/bin/olvm
Installing libol.so...
install libol.so /usr/lib/libol.so
Installing headers...
install -d /usr/include/ol
install -m 644 includes/ol/vm.h /usr/include/ol/vm.h
install -m 644 includes/ol/ol.h /usr/include/ol/ol.h
# and libraries to /usr/lib/ol:
Installing basic libraries...
cd libraries && find * -type d -exec install -d "{}" "/usr/lib/ol/{}" \;
cd libraries && find * -type f -exec install -m 644 "{}" "/usr/lib/ol/{}" \;
# install Ol binary REPL to /usr/lib/ol:
Installing REPL...
install -d /usr/lib/ol
install -m 644 repl /usr/lib/ol/repl
Installing man page...
install -d /usr/share/man/man1
gzip <ol.1 >/usr/share/man/man1/ol.1.gz
Ok.

~/Workspace/ol.git$ ./ol
Welcome to Otus Lisp 2.3.9-3574-5707caf6
type ',help' to help, ',quit' to end session.
> (import (scheme srfi-170))
> ;; Library (scheme srfi-170) added
> ;; Imported (scheme srfi-170)
> 

I'll recheck with fresh new VM.

[yuriy-chumak]

It works under fresh new VM without any changes.

@bentxt, try to make uninstall; make install.
OR
./ol --home=`pwd`/libraries in the Ol repository to test.

[lassik]

In Scheme we generally use (import (srfi 170)). RnRS reserves the (import (scheme <...>)) library namespace for itself. What's the rationale for diverging from this convention?

[yuriy-chumak]

What's the rationale

Historical reasons.
I haven't seen any srfi location standard, but you'r right I think... Hmmmm.

[yuriy-chumak]

• guile: (srfi srfi-1)
• chez: no srfi (?)
• chibi: (srfi 1)
• chicken: srfi-1
• gambit: (srfi 1)
• gauche: (srfi 1)
• kawa: (srfi :101)
• mit: (runtime srfi-1)
• racket: srfi/1
• stklos: (srfi 1)

Which one is better? ))

[lassik]

• In a recent MIT Scheme, try ,(import (srfi 1)) with the comma. It should work.
• In Chicken, try chicken-install r7rs && csi -R r7rs and (import (srfi 1)).
• Chez (and many other R6RS implementations) can use chez-srfi. The syntax then is (import (srfi :1)). The is : a hack due to a limitation in the R6RS standard that library name parts cannot be numbers.

[yuriy-chumak]

Libraries whose first identifier is srfi are reserved for libraries implementing Scheme Requests for Implementation.

Ah, I see!

Thank you. I'll update provided Ol's srfi implementations according to R⁷RS.

[lassik]

Excellent. Thank you very much!

[yuriy-chumak]

(import (scheme srfi-170)) works fine.
(import (srfi 170)) works fine.

Closing.
Feel free to open new one if needed.