If Java isn't Available, DMG Extraction Fails

[acook]

If Java isn't Available, DMG Extraction Fails

[Bioruebe]

I extracted some of my test files and it seems like 7z does not only work more reliable, but also supports files which fail to extract with DMGExtractor. All other files had the same output for both extractors.

At the end I choose option 1 and replaced DMGExtractor completely. Thanks for the tip.

[acook]

It looks like @Bioruebe added DMGExtractor last year in commit b88ac1d, was there a reason you didn't use 7zip?
Does DMGExtractor support a wider range of DMG formats?

The output for this particular DMG is identical between using DMGExtractor and 7Zip. (see below)

The options as I see them:

1. Remove DMGExtractor and use 7Zip for all DMGs
2. Try DMGExtractor and fallback to 7Zip if Java isn't available
3. Use 7Zip by default for DMGs but if extraction fails fallback to DMGExtractor

What does everyone else think?