ilyvion-contrib/gc-arena

Experimental system for rust garbage collection

This repo is home to the gc-arena crate, which provide Rust with garbage collected arenas and a means of safely interacting with them.

gc-arena

The gc-arena crate, along with its helper crate gc-arena-derive, provides safe allocation with cycle-detecting garbage collection within a closed "arena". There are two techniques at play that make this system sound:

• Garbage collected objects are traced using the Collect trait, which must be implemented correctly to ensure that all reachable objects are found. This trait is therefore unsafe, but it can safely be implemented by procedural macro, and the gc-arena-derive provides such a safe procedural macro.

• In order for garbage collection to take place, the garbage collector must first have a list of "root" objects which are known to be reachable. In our case, the user of gc-arena chooses a single root object for the arena, but this is not sufficient for safe garbage collection. If garbage collection were to take place when there are garbage collected pointers anywhere on the Rust stack, such pointers would also need to be considered as "root" objects to prevent memory unsafety. gc-arena solves this by strictly limiting where garbage collected pointers can be stored, and when they can be alive. The arena can only be accessed through a single mutate method which takes a callback, and all garbage collected pointers inside this callback are branded with an invariant lifetime which is unique to that single callback call. Thus, when outside of this mutate method, the rust borrow checker ensures that it is not possible for garbage collected pointers to be alive anywhere on the stack, nor is it possible for them to have been smuggled outside of the arena's root object. Since all pointers can be proven to be reachable from the single root object, safe garbage collection can take place.

In other words, the gc-arena crate does not retrofit Rust with a globally accessible garbage collector, rather it only allows for limited garbage collection in isolated garbage collected arenas. All garbage collected pointers must forever live inside only this arena, and pointers from different arenas are prevented from being stored in the wrong arena.

Use cases

This crate was developed primarily as a means of writing VMs for garbage collected languages in safe Rust, but there are probably many more uses than just this.

Current status and TODOs

Currently this crate is still pretty WIP, but is basically usable and safe.

The collection algorithm is an incremental mark-and-sweep algorithm very similar to the one in PUC-Rio Lua 5.3, and is optimized primarily for low pause time. During mutation, allocation "debt" is accumulated, and this "debt" determines the amount of work that the next call to Arena::collect will do.

The pointers held in arenas (spelled Gc<'gc, T>) are zero-cost raw pointers. They implement Copy and are pointer sized, and no bookkeeping at all is done during mutation.

Some notable current limitations:

• Allocating DSTs is currently somewhat painful due to limitations in Rust. It is possible to have Gc pointers to DSTs, and there is a replacement for unstable Unsize coercion, but allocating space for arbitrarily sized DSTs is currently pretty weird.

• There is currently no system for object finalization. This is not terribly difficult to implement, depending on the system, but it would require picking a particular set of edge-case finalization behavior. Implementing Drop for a type held inside a Gc ofc still works as normal though, so the actual need for genuine "finalization" is unclear.

• A harder to solve limitation is that there is currently no system for multi- threaded allocation and collection. The basic lifetime and safety techniques here would still work in an arena supporting multi-threading, but this crate does not support this. It is optimized for single threaded use and multiple, independent arenas.

• Another limitiation is that the Collect trait does not provide a mechanism to move objects once they are allocated, so this limits the types of collectors that could be written. This is achievable but no work has been done towards this.

• The crate is currently pretty light on documentation and examples.

Prior Art

The ideas here are mostly not mine, much of the design is borrowed heavily from rust-gc, and the idea of using "generativity" comes from You can't spell trust without Rust.

License

Everything in this repository is licensed under either of:

• MIT license LICENSE-MIT or http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT
• Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication LICENSE-CC0 or https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/

at your option.