ksp-ro / roengines Goto Github PK

Engine models and part configs to replace the generic Squad engines for Realism Overhaul

License: Other

C# 97.51% Python 2.49%

roengines's Introduction

ROEngines

What is it?

ROEngines is a mod that takes the best versions of engine models available and uses them as the in-game models for Realism Overhaul parts. The duplicate engines that exist in Realism Overhaul are removed.

Why is it needed?

Historically, Realism Overhaul has been a mod that provides only config files that change the sizes and values of existing parts from stock and mods. This has allowed the mod to represent many different parts and engines that existed historically. Often, these models are only close approximation of what the real life engines look like. Other times, these models are not accurate at all and are only used in order to fill a niche that is needed.

Duplicated parts are a common occurrance in Realism Overhaul. Players will often have multiple mods installed that will have the same engines configured. ROEngines fixes this problem by removing the duplicated engines and only representing a single version of the configured engine.

Many players will typically install mods for specific engines. This can lead to very large installs with parts that are unwanted just to get certain engines. This will hopefully fix some of those problems by offering a single source for many engines.

Who deserves the credit?

All the modders that used their time and considerable skills to develop the models, animations and textures that you see represented in game. Each part that is included inlcudes reference to the original modder that created the part. In all situations I have respected the licenses (as far as I know) and where authors could be reached, I received permission to include them. If you find anything that you do not think should belong, please let me know and I will remove them.

Dependencies

Module Manager
Realism Overhaul
B9PartSwitch
ROLibrary

These come bundled with the mod.

Patch Manager

Where are my Parts!?

ROEngines uses Module Manager and Patch Manager to remove the duplicated versions of the engines included in the mod. This way, you will only see one version of say an LR79, and it will be the version from ROEngines.

I understand that some of you may want these other versions of engines back, so I have used the Patch Manager mod to make this very easy for you to manage. Patch Manager allows you to select which Module Manager patches are applied. So for each engine that is included in ROEngines, you can choose to keep, or remove the patch that will hide the other variants, and the great thing is that it is all done through the KSP interface, no config editing required.

Using Patch Manager

Go to the Space Center screen and click the icon for Patch Manager
Inside the Window, click on the ROEngines button
By default, all patches are active. Active patches are green. When these patches are active, it means that ONLY the ROEngines version of the engine will show in your game. All other versions of the same engine will be removed.
To deactive a patch (allow duplicate engines), you simply click on the corresponding button. If the patch is disabled, it is shown in red.
Click the Apply All button on the bottom left of the window.
Use Patch Manager to shut down KSP, or click acknowledge and continue playing. Your patch will not be active until you restart KSP.

Parts Included

Liquid Engines (50+)
- A-4 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- Aerobee (Taerobee by Beale & CobaltWolf)
- Agena (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ10-137 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ10-190 (SSTU by ShadowMage)
- AJ10 Early (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ10 Mid (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ10 Advanced Short Nozzle (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ10 Advanced Long Nozzle (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- BE-3 (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- BE-4 (Provenance Aerospace by DylanSemrau & Superpenguin160)
- Bimodal NTR (Constellation Essentials by BahamutoD)
- C-1 (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- E-1 (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- F-1 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- F-1B (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- G-1 (Astral Manufactures by Al2Me6)
- Gamma-2 (CRE by Beale)
- Gamma-8 (CRE by Beale)
- Gamma-301 (CRE by Beale)
- H-1C (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- H-1D (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- HM7 (Astral Manufactures by Al2Me6)
- J-2, J-2S (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- J-2T (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- J-2X (SSTU by ShadowMage)
- LE-5 (Forgotten Real Engines by Zarbizaure)
- LE-7 (Forgotten Real Engines by Zarbizaure)
- LMAE (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- LMDE (RealEngines by Alcentar); TR-201 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR101 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR105 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR79 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR79/S-3 Vernier (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR87 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR87 Single (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR87 Extended Nozzle (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR87 Single Extended Nozzle (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR87-LH2 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR87-LH2 Vac (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR91 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR89 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR101 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR105 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- LR129 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- M-1 (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- MB-35 (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- MB-60 (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- Merlin Family (SSTU by ShadowMage)
- NERVA (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- NERVA II (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- NERVA XE Prime (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- NAA75-110 Redstone (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- NK-33 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- NK-43 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- ORM-65 (Custom Model by Basila)
- Ranger/Mariner Propulsion System (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- RD-0105 (RealEngines by Alcentar, model edits by Pap & Blowfish)
- RD-0110 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0110R (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0120 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0124 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0146 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0203 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0210 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0212 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0213 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-0214 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-100 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-107 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-108 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-111 (Custom Model by Basila)
- RD-119 (Soviet Rockets by RaiderNick)
- RD-170 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-180 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- RD-191 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-214 (Soviet Rockets by RaiderNick)
- RD-216 (Soviet Rockets by RaiderNick)
- RD-250 (Tantares LV by Beale)
- RD-252 (Tantares LV by Beale)
- RD-253/275 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-254 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-270/270M (CH-4 by Luci & TheBeastlyPig)
- RD-8 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-58 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-301 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- RD-855 (Tantares by Beale)
- RD-856 (Tantares by Beale)
- RL10 (fixed nozzle) (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- RL10A-4N (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- RL10B-2 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- RS-68 (Bluedog Design Bureau by Zorg)
- RS-25 SSME (with 35, 50, 77 and 150 AR nozzles) (Rocket Motor Menagerie by EStreetRockets)
- Rutherford (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- Rutherford Vacuum (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- RZ.20 (CRE by Beale)
- RZ Series (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- S-155 (CH-4 by Luci & TheBeastlyPig)
- S5.23 (Tantares LV by Beale)
- S5.92 (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- S5.98M (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- S2.253 (Modified RD-100 from RealEngines by Alcentar)
- SNTP-PFE100 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Stentor (CRE by Beale)
- Veronique (Modified RD-100 from RealEngines by Alcentar)
- Viking-2 (Forgotten Real Engines by Zarbizaure)
- Viking-4 (Forgotten Real Engines by Zarbizaure)
- Viking-5 (Forgotten Real Engines by Zarbizaure)
- X-405 Vanguard (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- X-405H Vega (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- XLR10 (Custom model by CobaltWolf)
- XLR11 (Astral Manufactures by Al2Me6)
- XLR25 (CH-4 by Luci & TheBeastlyPig)
- XLR41 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- XLR43 (RealEngines by Alcentar)
- XLR99 (CH-4 by Luci & TheBeastlyPig)
Solid Engines (19)
- Aerobee Aerojet 1.8KS7800 (US Rockets by RaiderNick)
- Aerobee Aerojet 2.5KS18000 (US Rockets by RaiderNick)
- Agena Retro Type III (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Agena Spin Rocket (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ60 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ-260 SL Radial (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ-260 SL Inline (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ-260 FL Radial (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- AJ-260 SL Inline (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Alcyone-1 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Algol 1 Radial (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Algol 1 Inline (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Algol 2 Radial (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Algol 2 Inline (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Altair (US Rockets by RaiderNick)
- Altair II (US Rockets by RaiderNick)
- Altair III (US Rockets by RaiderNick)
- Antares 1 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Antares 2 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Baby Sergeant (1x, 3x, 11x) (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 1 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 1 Inline (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 2 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 2 Inline (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 4 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 4AXL (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 30 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 30XL (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 120 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- GCRC (US Rockets by RaiderNick)
- GEM40 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- GEM46 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- GEM60 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- GEM63 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- M55 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Nike-M5E1 (Wrobz Sounding Rockets)
- SR19 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- SR73 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- SRMU (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- R-103 Booster (US Rockets by RaiderNick)
- S-IVB Ullage Motor (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Star-5D (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- Star-8 (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- Star-13/13A/13D (Bluedog Design Bureau by MockingBird)
- Star-17/17A (Bluedog Design Bureau by Invaderchaos)
- Star-37 (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Star-37E (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Star-37FM (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Star-48B (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- UA-1200 Series (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
Small Maneuvering / Landing Engines (13)
- Agena SPS (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- R-4D / HiPAT (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- LEROS-1b (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- LEROS-4 (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- MR-80B (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- MR-80-TDE (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- MR-104 (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- Phoenix Lander Engine (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- R-40B (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- R-42 (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- S-400 Thruster (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- SuperDraco (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- Dual SuperDraco (NicheParts by MockingBird)
- TD-339 (NicheParts by MockingBird)
Other Parts
- Agena D Equipment Rack (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Baby Sergeant 3x Decoupler (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Baby Sergeant 11x Decoupler (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- Castor 1 & 2 Decoupler (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- UA1200 Series Decoupler (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
- UA1200 Series Nosecone and Separation Motor (Bluedog Design Bureau by CobaltWolf)
Launch Clamps
- All from FASA which was originally created by Frizzank

roengines's People

Contributors

Stargazers

Watchers

Forkers

mattwrobel karlack26 docrockwell zantigar fat-lobyte gordon-dry gazpachian wade1990 lukecologne capkirk123 ackcen naet1 rcrockford lpgagnon dgfl-gh hebarusan t-liu93 andyoneal katniss218 vader111 thebeastlypig jeceratops branan tubbz-alt jwvanderbeck bubdm thedestroyerksp arcanemaniak ksp-realistic-revamp mhenion8293 novemberorwhatever arrowmaster uriyuzhui ilmcamam luneolucy dundun92 ryanc55 vlood27 jimmymcgoochie cybersys clayell ezsnackeur

roengines's Issues

PartLoader Errors

Environment: RO, ROEngines, B9PartSwitch, with clean-up from #78

Remaining issues:

Missing assets:
[ERR 10:43:38.125] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 10:43:38.126] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 10:43:38.128] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan_innerGlow' not found!
[ERR 10:43:40.598] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/RD120normal_NRM' not found!
[ERR 10:43:40.906] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RN/aerobee300_main' not found!
[ERR 10:43:41.195] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RN/kosmos2_rd119_NRM' not found!
[ERR 10:43:41.323] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RN/kosmos2_fs_tank' not found!
[ERR 10:43:42.334] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/SSTUKatniss/SC-ENG-J-2-DIFF' not found!
[ERR 10:43:42.336] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/SSTUKatniss/SC-ENG-J-2-NRM' not found!
[ERR 10:43:42.337] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/SSTUKatniss/SC-ENG-J-2-GLOW' not found!

Missing/invalid transform names:
[ERR 10:44:49.521] [ERROR] [Part ROE-Antares1.Inline] [ModuleB9DisableTransform] No transforms named 'Fairing' found in model
[ERR 10:44:49.780] [ERROR] [Part ROE-Antares2.Inline] [ModuleB9DisableTransform] No transforms named 'Fairing' found in model
[ERR 10:44:54.999] [ERROR] [Part ROE-LR79] [ModuleB9DisableTransform] No transforms named 'fairing' found in model
[ERR 10:44:55.155] [ERROR] [Part ROE-LR87.11] [ModuleB9DisableTransform] No transforms named 'fairing' found in model
[ERR 10:44:55.519] [ERROR] [Part ROE-LR87] [ModuleB9DisableTransform] No transforms named 'fairing' found in model
[ERR 10:44:59.430] [ERROR] [Part ROE-RD0120] [ModuleB9DisableTransform] No transforms named '43' found in model
[ERR 10:45:02.648] [ERROR] [Part ROE-RS27] [ModuleB9DisableTransform] No transforms named 'fairing' found in model

Decoupler config issues:
[LOG 10:44:50.297] PartLoader: Compiling Part 'ROEngines/PartConfigs/BabySergeant_RN/ROE-BabySergeantX3Dec'
[ERR 10:44:50.304] Cannot find fx group of that name for decoupler
(... also for the other two ROE-BabySergeant decouplers)

Unknown BDB requirements:
[LOG 10:44:53.737] PartLoader: Compiling Part 'ROEngines/PartConfigs/Jupiter_Vernier_BDB/ROE-JupiterVernier'
[ERR 10:44:53.754] Cannot find a PartModule of typename 'ModuleBdbDepthMask'

ModuleEnginesRF Vernier / Transforms:
[LOG 10:45:05.932] PartLoader: Compiling Part 'ROEngines/PartConfigs/X405_BDB/ROE-X405'
[ERR 10:45:05.945] [ModuleEnginesRF] no transforms named vernierEffects found

RD57 Engine

https://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/index.php?/topic/138467-wip-vodorod-engines-pack-for-ro-v01/

Error on Plume direction.

The rocket is ROE-A4, upgraded as A-9.

I hope it helps.

Greetings.

UPDATE, I haven't update for ROEngines v1.10.1, I already noticed now.

Add BDB Kick Stages

Add the Bluedog Inertial Upper Stage, Star 48B, and Star 37 to ROEngines, Opened after discussion on discord.

Stock Aerojet 2.5KS18000 not removed by Aerobee_Solids.cfg

The ReStock model for the Aerojet 2.5KS18000 is present in game even though the ROEngines patch in PatchManager/ActiveMMPatches/Aerobee_Solids should remove it. The model is also visually glitched, with the central orange-yellow band heavily flickering, so that should probably be fixed too

There's also an optional part variant for TU recoloring, but the textures are broken (although recoloring is working) and flickering is even heavier

Normalize Cost for non-RP situations [Bonus]

Well I'm not playing realistic progression now
However I sincerely hope that you can normalize RO Engines cost to a proper level (same as RP-1 is OK)
The cost problem has already been highly problematic in a bunch of engine packs like RealEngines pack,one part of the ROEngines.
That's because cost of most other parts are correct,but as for engines, they are highly incorrect for non-RP players :-(

SPE support

It's not clear to me whether the configs for this ought to live in ROEngines or SPEngine, but @pap1723 said to open an issue here.

SPE 'borrows' existing part models for its engines, with a smattering of dependencies on SXT, FASA, etc. It would be nice if it could use better models from ROEngines when those are available.

LR91 vernier transforms break roll control

The LR91 model from BDB uses and invisible second vernier to avoid causing asymmetrical thrust. However, both verniers seem to gimbal in the same direction, preventing roll from being applied. Further investigation needed, the second invisible vernier should probably be eliminated.

LR91 not working

The engine configs don't seem to initialize properly.

Missing textures

Per discord discussion: errors seen in KSP.log. Don't know if any represent actual problems.

Note a couple of missing models at the bottom

[ERR 08:30:52.031] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.031] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.073] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/metalPlaceholder' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.090] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.090] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.109] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.109] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.129] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.129] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Titan/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.207] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.207] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.207] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan_innerGlow' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.230] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan_innerGlow' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.230] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.230] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.271] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.271] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.271] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan_innerGlow' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.312] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.312] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.312] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan_innerGlow' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.353] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.354] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.354] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan_innerGlow' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.391] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan_innerGlow' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.391] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.391] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/BDB/UASRM/bluedog_Titan2_SecondStageTank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.912] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/Rcs2' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.912] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/Rcs2_nr_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:52.992] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/RD 191 em' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.018] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/RD 191 em' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.200] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/RD 170 Emissive texture' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.334] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/RD0210NR_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.386] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RealEngines/RD0210NR_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.733] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RN/kosmos2_fs_tank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.733] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RN/kosmos2_fs_tank_NRM' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.805] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RN/kosmos3_fs_tank' not found!
[ERR 08:30:53.805] Texture 'ROEngines/Assets/RN/kosmos3_fs_tank_NRM' not found!
[LOG 08:31:22.856] ERROR: Could not locate model: ROEngines/Assets/BDB/Agena/bluedog_agenaSecondaryEngine while applying KSP_MODEL_SHADER with name of: ROE-MetallicEngines
[LOG 08:31:23.235] ERROR: Could not locate model: ROEngines/Assets/RN/thor_castor while applying KSP_MODEL_SHADER with name of: ROE-SolidEngines
[LOG 08:31:23.237] ERROR: Could not locate model: ROEngines/Assets/RN/thor_castor2 while applying KSP_MODEL_SHADER with name of: ROE-SolidEngines

RemoveEngines nukes the SSTU Apollo Service module

Also kind of related, but what do you think about leaving the SSTU RD-107 and RD-108 parts in? They have really nice fairings, and an R-7 just isn't an R7 without the engine fairings.

Clean up Old Files / Improve Models

Part of the goal is to move away from SSTU to the higher fidelity models that might exist from BDB and elsewhere. Here is a list of which parts still use SSTU models.

~~ROE-Agena8048~~
ROE-AJ10-transtar (AJ-190)
~~ROE-J2~~
ROE-J2X
All of the Merlins
~~RD-107~~
~~RD-108~~
~~RD-0110~~
~~RD-170~~
~~RD-191~~
~~ROE-RL10A3~~
~~ROE-RL10A5~~
~~ROE-RL10B2~~
~~ROE-RS25~~

I don't know what options exist, just wanted to get these listed out.

ROE generic thrusters have turbopump ignition spoolup

They take ~2s to start producing any thrust after hitting the throttle. The RO generic thrusters on the other hand ignite within 0.1-0.2 seconds.
After some digging I found out that the minThrust and maxThrust fields are what make the RO thruster behave the way it is.

MODULE
{
	name = ModuleEnginesRF
	minThrust = 0
	maxThrust = 2
}

Not sure if we want to add those fields to ROE as well or try to find a better solution.

UA1207 nonfunctional

The UA1207 does not indicate any dV and does not ignite upon staging.

A-4 has the same model as RD-100

LR91 Vernier does not vector

The LR91 vernier does not seem to vector on any of the LR91 configurations. It does not animate, and cannot thrust vectoring, although it does produce thrust. The identical RN US rockets LR91 does have a functional vernier, so I assume some config data was merely copied wrong.

RL10 nozzle is always extended

I'm having some trouble with the rl10 engines nozzle extension. When i select the engine on the VAB, the nozzle is already extended, i was expecting that they will only extend after activating...

AJ10 Advanced engine bell is too wide

The historic usage of the AJ10-138 was Titan III Transtage, where two of them were placed on a 3.05m diameter stage. With the model currently in use, it is not possible to put two AJ10 Advanced inside a 3.05m outside diameter fairing.

0.592kN Dual Radial Engine no plume on Cavea-B

Not sure yet if this is only this engine, or all of ROEngines/PartConfigs/PLE_NicheParts.

0.592kN Dual Radial Engine running on HTP lacks plume, again

Part name: ROE-PLE

Engine Fairings

Almost all the engines have no way of removing the engine faring.

Wrong description on Viking Engines

All three of the Viking engines have the same description, assumed to be the description from the Viking 2 engine.

ROE-GCRC solid booster's throttle can be cut

Even though this engine says it cannot be shut down, I am still able to shut it down in flight (and thus restart it) by killing my throttle. This is the only solid that I've seen this behaviour on.

Provide pruner batch file for all affected mods

An OS dependent batch file for each supported OS and also a Janitor's Closet import file would be handy.

Those should prune (rename) every affected texture and model files which belong to the PART configs which are removed by ROEngines.

So the no more used textures and models are not loaded by KSP and waste RAM.

There is a slight chance that I will provide it, but don't rely on it.

Misplaced RCS-like engines

I noticed that two of the Niche Parts engines included as small RCS-like engines are misplaced and/or with strange configs.

The TD-339 is a bipropellant RCS-like engine in the Early landing node. I think it should be in Early Docking Procedures with the other bi-propellant RCS.
The R-4D is a very advanced (311 isp) RCS-like engine currently in Early Docking Procedures. Its description implies it's from much later, with mentions to Cassini and the Orion Capsule. Also, it has only 1 ignition, which doesn't make much sense for this kind of engine.

Include SSTU Engine-merging capability

In ROEngines the SSTU engines does are not as good as like original SSTU ones since they don't have tweakable mounts,engine cluster amount and a bunch of other varibles.
SSTU's engine-merging capability is truly amazing,as it make construction of heavy rockets much easier and also more beautiful(despite an unscientific point that SSTU engine mounts are massless no matter what size it is). However it is blocked by PatchManager of ROEngines, so I have to delete the PatchManager of ROEngines as a temporary choice :-( (the PM GUI also not work since I installed KSPIE and cannot open the ROEngines branch button.)
Another and much better solution is to use non-SSTU engine just meshes and introduce SSTU engine-merging capabilities and mounts to ALL engines. {highly recommended! for further development)(consider add mass of engine mount depend on engine cluster amount and type)
Also @shadowmage45 for this issue, looking forward to a happy RO collaborations!
I also love ROEngines since it is well-maintained (unlike REP abandoned in 1.3.1) and its most complete engine sets, fully RO-competatible and bugless.

add RD 701 and 704

Persistent Thrust Mod making RD-101/2/3 Plume not display

I am having an issue with the RD-101,102, 103 plumes not working on the RD-100 model. The RD-100 config works just fine but the other configs on that model do not seem to work. I noticed this problem while using the "Master" version of RO-Engines but I also tried replacing the RD-100 engine and plume configs from the release version of RO-Engines with no impact on Plumes. Randomly testing some other engine models like the A4 did not encounter this problem.

As a side not all of the ground dust particles that kick up on engine ignition display just no plume.

ROE-RS68 Engine Missing Mass In ROEngines/PartConfigs/RS68_SSTU.cfg

Module Manager is throwing an Error with SMURFF patches

[LOG 16:43:09.154] Applying update SMURFF/SMURFF/@part[*]:HAS[@resource[Ablator],~SMURFFExclude[*rue]]:FOR[zzz_SMURFF] to ROEngines/PartConfigs/RS68_SSTU.cfg/PART[ROE-RS68]
[WRN 16:43:09.155] Cannot find key mass in PART
[ERR 16:43:09.155] Error - Cannot parse variable search when replacing (%) key initialmass = #$mass$

Not sure if the Engines a are supposed to have an ablator and are supposed to have no mass? Also what mass are they supposed to have before or without SMURFF?

NK-15V uses NK-43 model, which is too large.

I mentioned this one on the discord but I figured I should keep track of it here. NK-15V/NK-43 uses the NK-43 model which is larger, making it unusable as N1 engine.
RNs NK-15V
ROEs NK-15V

Perhaps the NK-15V/NK-43 need to be split into separate engine parts instead of a config.

RD-107-117 and RD-108-118 vernors do not upgrade along with main engine

The ROEngines version for the RD-107/108 engines and its derivatives features two different engines:
The main engine and the small vernor engines. While this may seem like a good idea at first, there are two main problems with it:

The vernors are not upgraded along with the main engine. This means that the mixture ratios will be incorrect. That's especially problematic for the RD-117/RD-118 variants which use Syntine instead of Kerosene, while the vernors on the same part still use Kerosene
The Vernors do not respect ullage and ignition rules, and can be restarted arbitrarily.

Is there a way to simply drop the separate config for the vernors, add vectoring to the main engines and make only the model act like the vernor engines are moving?

Is @raidernick's CC-BY-NC-ND license being obeyed?

From the forum takedown announcement for the "Buran Energia Mod-Rebalanced and Fixed" mod:

This is suggestive that ROEngines may have a licensing problem with some of its content.

Chatting with @raidernick (including here to confirm authorial intent, happy to remove if @raidernick considers publicly sharing these private messages to be a privacy violation):

This "RN" folder seems to contain @raidernick's content:

https://github.com/KSP-RO/ROEngines/tree/master/GameData/ROEngines/Assets/RN

I'm not necessarily in the loop on all of the relevant backstory here, so my question is:
Is the ROEngines mod distributing an unauthorized derivative of @raidernick's work?

Castor decouplers don't decouple

In the latest merged version, Castor Decouplers don't decouple even when hooked up properly.

add RD 701 and 704

Just cool engines

AJ Advanced gimbal non-functional

The engine states it has a gimbal in description, but no gimbal, either functional or animated is actually present.

See here.

https://gfycat.com/weakfavoritedungenesscrab

2.2kN thruster

There's pretty ROE models for the other thrusters but not this one. Rescale something?

RD-180 gimbal breaks if the engine is rotated

If the RD-180 is rotated 90 (or 270) degrees about the roll axis from it's default rotation, the pitch and yaw gimbals stop working. This is probably due to some odd interaction with the multiple gimbal modules of the RD-180, since unlocking all gimbal axis allows it to work correctly again.

ROE generic thrusters are all over the place

A longstanding issue, but now I'm thinking of actually doing something about it.

ROE-PLE, ROE-MR104, ROE-S400 aren't configured in a way that's consistent with the base RO 1kN/2kN generic thrusters

all 3 have the same thrust, despite very different model sizes
all 3 have a thrust rating in their Title, but it's completely disconnected from their actual thrust
the 3 part names (and 2 of the Titles) reference specific real-world engines, but their only relationship to those engines seems to be the model
2 have the same mass, consistent with 1kN, but the 3rd is much lighter
the biggest of them is about the same size as the 1kN thruster, but half the thrust

Proposed requirements:

all 3 should produce different thrust, to give more options.
- 1 should provide the same thrust as the 1kN, for the sake of just offering a nicer model
- 1 should provide half the thrust, as all 3 currently do
- 1 should provide half again the thrust, for even smaller applications that are currently poorly supported.
all 3 should have mass "proportional" to their thrust, following standard RO rules (only the ROE-PLE needs a fix; it's currently set to explicitly override the mass RO would set)
all 3 should be scaled to fit their thrust
all 3 should have a less misleading Title. Just a (correct) thrust rating, no reference to real-world parts

Concrete changes this translates to:

ROE-S400 keeps its size (close to 1kN thruster) and gets double current thrust
ROE-MR104 keeps its size (maybe enlarged a bit?), gets half current thrust
ROE-PLE is scaled up so 1 nozzle is the same size as ROE-MR104, keeps current thrust
ROE-PLE useRcsMass = False becomes useRcsMass = True

BUT in the interest of not breaking any vessels, the current parts should be left untouched and deprecated via techrequired=undefined, category=-1. New parts should be created with the proposed changes, named ROE-generic-1/2/3 or similar

Phase 2:
At some point, might want to consider adding actual dual-MR107, MR104, S400 engines to ROEngines, since we have models that are presumably suitable. This is more work (would need RO engine configs), and there's already lots of small thrusters, so not a high priority. (such parts would presumably get named ROE-MR104-v2 etc)

Add NK-9, NK-9V and their variants

Those are some really nice engines.

RD-0105 does not remove the other models

Just a reminder that the RD-0105 model is not removing the other models available.

R-7 engine verniers can move in two axes

The two RD-107 and four RD-108 verniers are currently capable of moving in two axes. IRL the two vernier chambers on the RD-107 could only move in one axis, and each pair of the RD-108's verniers could only move in one axis as well.

Multiple Engines miss Gimbal

Several engines, like the NK-33 and NK-43 do not have a gimbal. This is because their ModuleGimbal is missing the MODULE keyword above the opening brace.

RL89 engine weights 0.0007 t

Gamma 2 Engine Stats off

I came across a source that would seem to indicate that the Gamma 2 engine stats are a little off. http://www.astronautix.com/g/gamma2.html seems to imply that the burn time should be 113s not 140s and that the ISP should be 265 (vac) 251(sea level) rather than the 267(vac)/ 189 (sea level). All the other engine stats seem to be pretty much bang on with this data source.

More engines from Niche Parts

https://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/index.php?/topic/144157-113-nicheparts-v142-real-engine-pack/ some more engines for you to consider pap. They all have RO configs most are RP-0 ready, the licence lets you use them, plus it adds more engines later to the tree.