kula87/kularepo

first repo

Logging Strategy Guidelines

Logging Strategy Guidelines provide best practices to create efficient logging systems, ensuring consistency, security, and easy analysis throughout an application or organization.

1. Logging Levels

Logging levels are crucial for categorizing log messages by severity and importance, aiding developers and support teams in filtering and analyzing logs more efficiently.

• DEBUG: Variable values, internal states, execution flow
• INFO: Application start-up/shutdown, significant events/ops, No sensitive information
• WARN: Configuration issues, deprecated API usage, Performance-related concerns
• ERROR: Exception details, stack traces, relevant context data
• FATAL: Critical issues that require immediate attention

2. Logging Pattern and Structure

Standardize the log message format, which should include, but not be limited to:

• Timestamp (ISO 8601 format)
• Log level
• Application or module name
• IP address (if applicable)
• Transaction ID
• Message (with clear and concise descriptions)
• Any relevant contextual data (e.g., user ID, request parameters)

2.1.1 Timestamp (ISO 8601 format)

The timestamp format in the provided examples is in ISO 8601 format, which is a widely used international standard for date and time representations. The format is as follows:

YYYY-MM-DDTHH:mm:ssZ

Example format:

Format	Description	Example
yyyy-MM-ddTHH:mm:ssZ	ISO 8601 format with a time zone offset expressed in hours	2023-05-08T14:30:15+09:00
yyyy-MM-ddTHH:mm:ss.SSSZ	ISO 8601 format with milliseconds and a time zone offset in hours	2023-05-08T14:30:15.123+09:00

Including local time in logs isn't advised, as it may cause confusion when correlating events. However, if needed, add a field like "japan_time" to log entries.

{ "timestamp": "2023-05-08T14:35:10.123Z", "japan_time": "2023-05-08T23:35:10.123+09:00", "level": "INFO", "message": "User login successful", "userId": "12345", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.1" }

2.1.2 Log level

Two tables clarify logging levels and environments. Table A details levels, logged info, and actions; Table B shows common levels for development, testing, staging, and production.

Table A

Level	Information to be logged	Action to be taken
DEBUG	Variable values, internal states, execution flow	Diagnose and debug issues
INFO	Application start-up/shutdown, significant events/ops, No sensitive information	Monitor app state and behavior
WARN	Configuration issues, deprecated API usage, Performance-related concerns	Investigate potential problems
ERROR	Exception details, stack traces, relevant context data	Resolve errors and exceptions
FATAL	Critical issues that require immediate attention	Address critical failures

Table B

Environment	Level
DEV	Free to use any level. DEBUG or INFO level is commonly set up.
TEST	Free to use any level. DEBUG or INFO level is commonly set up.
STG	Free to use any level. INFO level is appropriate, DEBUG is optional.
PROD	INFO, WARN, ERROR, and FATAL levels. DEBUG level is generally disabled in production.

2.1.3 Application or module name

The application or module name in logs helps identify the source of log messages, improving traceability and facilitating troubleshooting.

2.1.4 IP address (if applicable)

The IP address in logs, when applicable, provides information about the client or server involved in an event, aiding in the identification of potential security issues or debugging network-related problems.

2.1.5 Transaction ID

Using a standard transaction ID for log entries related to one request or operation aids tracing, debugging, and monitoring. Here's more on transaction IDs' importance and implementation.

Table summarizing the key aspects of using a standard transaction ID across all log entries related to a single request or operation.

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example	Sample Patterns	Summary Description
Transaction ID	A unique identifier assigned to each request or operation	Allows for correlation and tracing of logs related to a single transaction	UUID, GUID, or a custom format	c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21	UUID as a transaction ID
Propagate ID	Ensure the transaction ID is passed between internal and external API calls, services, and components	Helps maintain the traceability of logs across distributed systems	Pass the transaction ID in HTTP headers, message queues, or other communication methods	X-Request-ID: c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21	Transaction ID passed via HTTP header
Include ID in logs	Include the transaction ID in each log entry related to the request or operation	Allows logs to be filtered and aggregated based on the transaction ID	Add the transaction ID to the log entry structure	"transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21"	Transaction ID in log entry
Use standard format	Use a consistent format for transaction IDs across all applications and systems	Facilitates log correlation and analysis, regardless of the application or system generating the logs	Stick to a standardized format like UUID or GUID	-	Consistent ID format
Log analysis	Use log analysis tools that support transaction ID-based filtering and correlation	Simplifies the process of tracing logs related to a single request or operation	Configure Splunk or Kibana to recognize and filter logs based on the transaction ID	-	Log filtering by transaction ID

2.1.6 Message

Message: The main content of a log entry that describes the event or action, usually in a clear and concise manner. For example, "User logged in" or "File upload failed."

2.1.7 Contextual data

Contextual Data: Additional information that accompanies the message to provide context and help in understanding the event. It includes details like user ID, request parameters, file name, or transaction amount. For example, for a "User logged in with ID" message, the contextual data could be the user's ID and login timestamp. Such as, "User logged in with ID 123", "File 'report.pdf' not found", or "Payment of $50 processed successfully for user 456".

2.1.7.1 Logging patterns

Aspect	Sample Pattern	Summary Description
API Request	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:30.123Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "GET /api/v1/users", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.100"}	API GET request with transaction ID and IP address
API Response	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:30.567Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "API response", "statusCode": 200, "responseTime": 444}	API response with status code and response time
Database Query	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:30.678Z", "level": "DEBUG", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "SELECT * FROM users", "dbTime": 111}	Database query with query execution time
User Login	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:30.789Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "User login", "userId": "12345", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.100"}	User login event with user ID and IP address
External API Call	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:30.987Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Calling external API", "url": "https://api.example.com/data"}	External API call with API URL
Exception	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:31.234Z", "level": "ERROR", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Exception occurred", "error": "NullPointerException", "stackTrace": "..."}	Exception with error type and stack trace
Performance Warning	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:31.345Z", "level": "WARN", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Slow query", "query": "SELECT * FROM large_table", "duration": 2000}	Performance warning with slow query and duration
Configuration Issue	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:31.456Z", "level": "WARN", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Deprecated configuration option used", "option": "old_setting"}	Configuration issue with deprecated
Cache Hit	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.345Z", "level": "DEBUG", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Cache hit", "key": "user_12345"}	Cache hit event with cache key
Cache Miss	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.456Z", "level": "DEBUG", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Cache miss", "key": "user_67890"}	Cache miss event with cache key
File Upload	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.567Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "File upload", "userId": "12345", "fileName": "document.pdf", "fileSize": 1048576}	File upload event with user ID, file name, and file size
Scheduled Task	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.678Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Scheduled task started", "taskName": "daily_cleanup"}	Scheduled task started with task name
Task Completion	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.789Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Task completed", "taskName": "daily_cleanup", "duration": 3000, "result": "success"}	Task completion event with task name, duration, and result

2.1.7.2 Anti logging patterns

Avoid logging personal data, implicit secrets, and unstructured data, as these anti-patterns can lead to privacy violations, exposed sensitive information, and difficult log analysis.

Aspect	Sample Anti-Pattern	Summary Description
Sensitive Info	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.345Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "User logged in", "username": "johndoe", "password": "myp@ssw0rd"}	Logging sensitive information like passwords
Large Payload	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.456Z", "level": "DEBUG", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "HTTP response received", "response": "{...large JSON payload...}"}	Logging very large payloads that can impact performance and storage
Verbose Log	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.567Z", "level": "DEBUG", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Step 1 completed", "details": "Very long and detailed explanation of step 1..."}	Logging excessively verbose messages that can make it hard to find relevant information
Stack Trace as Message	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.678Z", "level": "ERROR", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Exception: NullPointerException, Stack Trace: ...long stack trace..."}	Logging stack traces as part of the log message instead of using a separate field for it
Missing Context	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.789Z", "level": "ERROR", "message": "File not found"}	Logging error messages without sufficient context, such as a transaction ID or related data
Hardcoded Log Level	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.890Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "DEBUG: Variable value changed", "variableName": "counter", "newValue": 5}	Hardcoding log levels in log messages, making it harder to filter logs based on level
SQL Queries	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.901Z", "level": "DEBUG", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "Executing SQL query", "query": "SELECT * FROM users WHERE username='johndoe' AND password='myp@ssw0rd'"}	Logging raw SQL queries, which can expose sensitive information and increase the risk of SQL injection attacks
Aspect	Sample Anti-Pattern	Summary Description
-------	---------------------	-------------------
Personal Data	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.912Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "New user registered", "name": "John Doe", "email": "[email protected]", "address": "123 Main St", "ssn": "123-45-6789"}	Logging personally identifiable information (PII) which may violate privacy laws and regulations
Implicit Secrets	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.923Z", "level": "INFO", "transactionId": "c1a89a5b-2075-4e72-a9a1-0e6cddbf0a21", "message": "API call", "url": "https://api.example.com/v1/users?apiKey=abc123"}	Logging URLs or other data containing sensitive information like API keys or access tokens
Unstructured Data	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:45:32.934Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "2023-05-08 15:45:32 [INFO] User logged in: johndoe"}	Logging unstructured data, which can make it difficult to parse and analyze the logs

2.1.7.2 Anti logging patterns

Logging standards for API calls can vary depending on the organization and the project. However, the general guidelines to follow when logging request and response data for GET and POST API calls.

Request Type	Description	Sample Pattern	About Sample Pattern
GET Request	Log request parameters and metadata	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:30:00.000Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "GET request", "url": "/api/v1/resource", "queryParams": {"id": "1234"}, "headers": {"User-Agent": "Mozilla/5.0"}}	Example of a log entry for a GET request, including request metadata, URL, query parameters, and headers
GET Response	Log response body, status code, and metadata	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:30:00.200Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "GET response", "url": "/api/v1/resource", "statusCode": 200, "responseBody": {"data": {"id": "1234", "name": "example"}}}	Example of a log entry for a GET response, including response metadata, status code, and response body
POST Request	Log request body, request parameters, and metadata	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:32:00.000Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "POST request", "url": "/api/v1/resource", "requestBody": {"id": "1234", "name": "example"}, "headers": {"Content-Type": "application/json"}}	Example of a log entry for a POST request, including request metadata, URL, request body, and headers
POST Response	Log response body, status code, and metadata	{"timestamp": "2023-05-08T15:32:00.300Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "POST response", "url": "/api/v1/resource", "statusCode": 201, "responseBody": {"result": "success", "id": "1234"}}	Example of a log entry for a POST response, including response metadata, status code, and response body

2.1.7.4 Casing standard

In logging, no strict casing standard exists. However, common conventions and best practices help maintain consistency and readability. Table summarizing the lowercase/uppercase conventions for various aspects of logging:

Aspect	Convention	Example
Log Levels	Uppercase	"INFO", "DEBUG", "WARN", "ERROR", "FATAL"
JSON Keys	camelCase/snake_case	"responseTimeMs", "response_time_ms"
Component Names	PascalCase/camelCase/snake_case	"Auth", "apiRequest", "api_request"
Log Messages	Sentence case	"User successfully logged in"

These are general guidelines, and the most important aspect is to maintain consistency throughout the log messages and follow the conventions used within the project.

3. Logging Output

• JSON format
• Plain text format

4. Logging Storage Rules

Logging Storage Rules cover storage location, retention, rotation, and backup/archiving for effective log management.

4.1. Storage Location

The storage location is vital for log data security, accessibility, and manageability. Various options, each with pros and cons, exist for storing log data.

Table summarizing various storage locations for log data:

Storage Location	Description	Pros	Cons
Local Disk	Store logs on the system where they're generated	Easy to set up, low cost	Limited space, single point of failure
Centralized Log Server	Send logs to a dedicated server	Simplified management, better security	Increased network traffic, setup complexity
Cloud-based Storage	Store logs on cloud platforms like AWS, GCP	Scalable, high availability	Costs, potential latency
Database	Store logs in a relational or NoSQL database	Structured data, easy querying	Complexity, performance impact
Log Management Service	Use third-party services like Splunk, ELK	Scalable, feature-rich	Costs, vendor lock-in

Here's a table summarizing the factors to consider when choosing a storage location for your logs:

Factor	Description
Security	Ensure the storage location provides adequate protection against unauthorized access, tampering, or loss of log data.
Accessibility	The storage location should be easily accessible to developers, support teams, and log management tools.
Scalability	Choose a storage location that can handle your log data volume and scale as your logging needs grow.
Retention & Archiving	Consider log retention and archiving policies required by your organization or regulations, and ensure compatibility.
Cost	Factor in storage and maintenance costs, including hardware, software, and operational expenses.

4.2. Retention Period

Retention period refers to the length of time that log data is stored and maintained before it is either deleted or archived.

Table summarizing the aspects to consider when determining a retention period for your logs:

Aspect	Description	Example	About Example
Regulatory Compliance	Legal requirements and industry regulations may dictate the retention period	GDPR requires log data containing personal data to be retained for no longer than necessary	In the EU, organizations must comply with GDPR's data retention requirements
Operational Needs	Retention period should align with the operational needs and use cases for log data	Retaining logs for 30 days to support troubleshooting, root cause analysis, and trend analysis	A company may decide 30 days is sufficient for their operational needs
Performance & Storage	Balancing the need for longer retention periods with the cost and performance implications of storing large volumes of log data	Storing logs for 6 months on a dedicated storage server, then archiving them offsite	A compromise between retaining logs and managing storage costs and performance
Security & Incident Response	Longer retention periods may be necessary for detecting and responding to security incidents	Retaining logs for 90 days to support the detection of slow, low-volume attacks	This allows security teams to identify patterns and trends over an extended period
Business Requirements	Retention period should meet any specific business requirements or policies	An organization may require logs to be retained for 1 year for auditing and compliance purposes	The organization's policy dictates a specific retention period based on their unique needs

4.3. Rotation Strategy

Log rotation or log rolling, is a technique used to manage log files by periodically renaming, compressing, or deleting them as they grow in size or age.

Table summarizing the common log rotation techniques and considerations:

Here's the revised table summarizing the common log rotation techniques with their descriptions, pros, and cons:

Technique	Description	Pros	Cons
Time-based Rotation	Rotate log files based on time intervals (e.g., daily, weekly, monthly)	Predictable rotation schedule, easy to manage	May result in large log files if log generation rate is high
Size-based Rotation	Rotate log files when they reach a specific size limit	Prevents excessive disk space usage	Frequent rotations if log generation rate is high or size limit is low
Log File Count	Maintain a specified number of log files, deleting or archiving the oldest when the limit is reached	Controls disk space usage, recent log data readily available	May lose older log data if file count is low or log generation rate is high
Compression	Compress older log files to save disk space while retaining data for future reference	Saves disk space while retaining log data	Increases time required to access and analyze compressed log data
Deletion or Archiving	Delete or archive log files that exceed a specific age or size limit to enforce retention policies	Enforces retention policies, controls disk space usage	May lose historical log data if not properly managed
Manual Intervention	Administrators periodically review and manage log files	Greater control over log management	Time-consuming, prone to errors

4.4. Backup and Archiving Policies

While the previous descriptions focused on log rotation and retention, backup and archiving policies are broader concepts that encompass the entire process of preserving log data for long-term storage and access.

Table summarizing the key aspects to consider when defining backup and archiving policies for log data:

Aspect	Description
Data Integrity	Ensure authenticity and integrity of stored data through checksums, digital signatures, etc.
Storage Media	Choose durable, accessible, and cost-effective storage media (e.g., tape, HDDs, cloud).
Redundancy	Protect against data loss with multiple copies, different locations, or storage media.
Security	Use encryption, access controls, and other security measures to protect stored data.
Disaster Recovery	Integrate policies with disaster recovery and business continuity plans.
Regular Testing	Periodically test backup and archiving processes to verify effectiveness and data retrieval.
Compliance	Comply with relevant regulations, legal requirements, and contractual obligations.
Documentation	Document policies, procedures, and responsibilities; provide guidance and training.

5. Logging Rules

5.1. Exclude Critical or Sensitive Information

Excluding critical or sensitive information from logs is crucial for ensuring data security, privacy, and compliance with various regulations.

Table summarizing the key aspects to consider when excluding critical or sensitive information from logs:

Aspect	Description	What/How to do it
Identify sensitive data	Determine types of data considered sensitive or critical in your context	Define a list of sensitive data types (Personally Identifiable Information [PII], financial data, credentials, etc.)
Data masking or redaction	Hide or remove sensitive information from log entries	Replace sensitive data with placeholders, asterisks, or other non-revealing characters
Log sanitization	Ensure third-party libraries/components don't log sensitive information	Configure logging settings of components or implement custom log sanitization logic
Access controls	Limit who can view or modify log data containing sensitive information	Implement strict access controls; grant access only to authorized personnel
Encryption	Protect log data from unauthorized access or tampering	Encrypt log data at rest and in transit
Auditing and monitoring	Detect and respond to unauthorized access or data leakage incidents	Regularly audit and monitor log data; establish clear incident response procedures
Compliance	Comply with relevant industry standards and legal requirements	Follow data security and privacy regulations; retain log data for specific periods
Employee training	Ensure employees understand and follow rules for handling sensitive data	Provide training on logging, data management, and security best practices

5.2. Standard Transaction ID

Using a standard transaction ID across all log entries related to a single request or operation is a best practice that helps in tracing, debugging, and monitoring application activities.

Table summarizing the key aspects of using a standard transaction ID across all log entries related to a single request or operation:

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do it
Purpose	Correlate log entries across components, services, systems for a specific request/operation	Trace, debug, and monitor application activities
Generation	Create a unique identifier for each request or operation	Use UUIDs, timestamps, or combinations of unique identifiers (e.g., user/request ID)
Propagation	Ensure consistent usage of transaction ID throughout the execution path	Pass ID as a parameter, use request headers, or store in a context object
Logging	Include transaction ID in every related log entry	Add the transaction ID as a field in log entry structure or as part of the log message
Searching & correlation	Quickly search and filter log entries related to a specific request or operation	Improve troubleshooting, performance analysis, and incident response; correlate log entries from different sources

5.2. Sanitize log data to prevent log injection attacks

Log injection attacks occur when an attacker manipulates log entries by injecting malicious data, often through user input fields, to gain unauthorized access, alter system behavior, or cause other security issues. Sanitizing log data is crucial for preventing log injection attacks and maintaining the integrity and security of your application.

Table summarizing the key aspects of sanitizing log data to prevent log injection attacks:

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do it
Input validation	Ensure user input and external data meet expected format, length, and content requirements	Prevent injection of malicious data; reject or sanitize non-conforming input
Encoding & escaping	Encode or escape unsafe characters or strings in log data	Avoid execution of malicious scripts/commands; protect log integrity
Parameterized logging	Separate log messages from data values	Reduce log injection risk; use placeholders in log messages & pass data as arguments
Log data filtering	Remove or replace known malicious patterns, keywords, or characters from log data	Prevent malicious data from being written to logs; maintain log security
Monitoring & alerting	Monitor log data for signs of log injection attacks and set up alerts	Detect unusual patterns, unexpected data, or suspicious activity; notify relevant personnel
Updates & security patches	Keep logging libraries, frameworks, and components up to date with security patches	Protect against known log injection vulnerabilities; follow best practices

5.2.1 input validation to prevent log injection attacks

Input validation should be performed at multiple levels to ensure maximum security and protection against log injection attacks or other potential threats. Table summarizing the key places where input validation should be done to prevent log injection attacks or other potential threats:

Level	Description	Why/What/How to do it
Client-side	Validate input using JavaScript or other client-side scripting languages	Prevent malformed/malicious data submission; not to be relied on exclusively
Server-side	Perform validation in each application that receives user input or external data	More secure than client-side validation; validate in controllers, services, or middleware
Web Application Firewall (WAF)	Security layer between client and server to filter and monitor HTTP traffic	Validate input data, block malicious requests; adds extra security layer
Logging component	Validate any data received before writing it to log files	Prevent log injection attacks; ensure only valid data is recorded

5.2.2 Encode or escape unsafe characters or strings in log data

Encoding and escaping transform unsafe characters in log data into a safe format, preventing log injection attacks and maintaining log data security and integrity.

Table summarizing the key aspects of encoding and escaping unsafe characters or strings in log data:

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example
HTML encoding	Transform unsafe HTML characters	Prevent script execution in logs	<script> becomes &lt;script&gt;
URL encoding	Encode special characters in URLs	Maintain log data structure/integrity	"key=value&test" becomes "key%3Dvalue%26test"
Escaping control characters	Escape control characters like newline, carriage return	Prevent formatting issues in logs	"User logged in\nUser ID: 123" becomes "User logged in\nUser ID: 123"

5.2.3 Parameterized logging

Parameterized logging uses placeholders in messages and separates data values, ensuring clean log format, easier parsing, and reduced risk of log injection attacks.

Table summarizing the key aspect of parameterized logging:

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example
Parameterized logging	Separate log messages from data values using placeholders	Maintain log format, reduce log injection risk	"User {} has a balance of ${}." for log message, then use .format(username, balance) to insert data values. This format "User " + username + " has a balance of $" + str(balance) + "." is not recommended.

5.2.4 Log data filtering

Log data filtering refers to the practice of sanitizing log data by identifying and handling potentially harmful content before writing it to logs. This approach helps prevent log injection attacks, maintain log data integrity, and improve application security.

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example	Script Pattern
Log data filtering	Remove or replace known malicious patterns, keywords, or characters from log data	Prevent log injection attacks and protect sensitive data	{ "message": "User <script>alert(1)</script> login failed" }	{ "message": "User [REMOVED] login failed" }
			{ "message": "File <img src=x onerror=alert(1)> deleted" }	{ "message": "File [REMOVED] deleted" }

5.2.5 Monitoring & alerting

Monitoring and alerting involve scanning log data to identify patterns, keywords, or characters that may indicate a log injection attack. By setting up alerts, enabling security teams to quickly respond and maintain application security and integrity.

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example
Regular expressions and pattern matching	Identify log injection patterns and keywords	Efficiently search and detect malicious patterns in log data	Regular expression to match common script tags: <\s*script.*>
Log analysis tools	Automated log scanning and detection	Tools like Splunk and ELK Stack can analyze logs for suspicious patterns	Setting up log parsing rules in Splunk to detect log injection attempts
Threshold-based alerting	Set up alerts based on thresholds	Trigger alerts when a certain number of log injection attempts are detected	Alert when more than 10 log injection attempts occur within an hour
Real-time monitoring	Continuously monitor log data	Immediate detection and response to log injection attacks	Real-time log monitoring dashboard showing injection attempts and response times
Incident response plan	Develop a plan for responding to log injection attacks	Ensure timely and effective response to detected threats	Plan includes steps for investigating, mitigating, and reporting log injection incidents

5.2.6 Updates & security patches

Regularly update logging libraries and frameworks to protect against known security vulnerabilities, mitigating log injection attacks and unauthorized access.

Table summarizing the key aspects of keeping logging libraries, frameworks, and components up to date with security patches:

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example
Regular updates	Schedule regular updates of logging libraries, frameworks, and components	Ensure latest versions with recent security patches	Update logging libraries every month or as patches are released
Security advisories	Subscribe to security advisories and updates related to logging components	Stay informed about new vulnerabilities and patches	Subscribe to mailing lists or RSS feeds for used logging libraries
Vulnerability scanning	Use vulnerability scanning tools to identify outdated or vulnerable components	Detect vulnerable logging components in your application	Use tools like OWASP Dependency-Check to scan your application
Dependency management	Implement a dependency management process to track and manage logging components	Ensure all components are up to date and secure	Use package managers like npm, Maven, or Gradle to manage dependencies
Automated testing	Verify application functionality after updating logging components	Catch compatibility issues or bugs introduced by updates	Set up automated tests using tools like JUnit or Selenium

6. Testing the Log Pattern

Testing log patterns ensures consistency, accuracy, and proper formatting, helping to meet quality standards for debugging, monitoring, and auditing.

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example
Log format validation	Verify the log format is consistent with the defined log structure and pattern	Test logs against a predefined schema or structure	Test a log entry against a predefined schema to ensure it contains the required fields
Content validation	Check that log entries contain necessary information and context; no sensitive data is logged	Test log entries for different scenarios and verify the required information	Test log entries for successful transactions, failed login attempts, and application errors
Timestamp accuracy	Ensure timestamp is accurate, precise (includes milliseconds), and follows a consistent format	Generate log entries at known times and compare the logged timestamps	Generate log entries at known times and compare the logged timestamps against actual times
Log level correctness	Validate log entries are generated at the correct log level, based on severity and importance	Test different scenarios with varying severity levels and verify log levels	Test scenarios with severity levels (debug, info, warn, error, fatal) and verify log levels
Log rotation & retention	Test log rotation and retention policies to ensure logs are properly rotated, archived, and purged	Simulate log growth over time and verify log rotation and retention policies	Simulate log growth over time and verify log rotation occurs, and older logs are archived

7. Integration with Existing Tools (Splunk and Kibana)

Design a logging strategy with Splunk and Kibana compatibility for easy log aggregation, filtering, and analysis, enabling your team to efficiently extract insights.

Aspect	Description	Why/What/How to do	Example	Sample Log Entry Patterns	Summary Description about Sample Pattern
Log format (JSON)	Use JSON for log output to ensure structured logging and easy parsing.	JSON format allows for better organization and parsing of log data, making it easier to work with in Splunk & Kibana.	User login successful	{ "timestamp": "2023-05-08T14:35:10.123Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "User login successful", "userId": "12345", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.1" }	JSON structure makes logs easily parsable by Splunk and Kibana.
Field naming	Use consistent and recognizable field names in log data.	Consistent field names make it easier to aggregate, filter, and analyze log data in Splunk & Kibana.	User login successful	{ "timestamp": "2023-05-08T14:35:10.123Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "User login successful", "userId": "12345", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.1" }	Recognizable field names improve log data management in Splunk and Kibana.
Timestamp format (ISO 8601)	Use ISO 8601 format for timestamps in log data.	ISO 8601 timestamps are easily recognizable and supported by Splunk & Kibana.	User login successful	{ "timestamp": "2023-05-08T14:35:10.123Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "User login successful", "userId": "12345", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.1" }	ISO 8601 timestamps ensure compatibility with Splunk and Kibana.
Structured logging	Include additional context and metadata in log data as separate fields.	Structured logging improves the ability to search, filter, and analyze log data in Splunk & Kibana.	User login successful	{ "timestamp": "2023-05-08T14:35:10.123Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "User login successful", "userId": "12345", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.1", "apiEndpoint": "/login", "httpMethod": "POST", "responseCode": 200 }	Structured logging enhances log data analysis capabilities in Splunk and Kibana.
Indexing and source types	Configure log indexing and source types in Splunk and Kibana.	Proper indexing and source type configurations improve log data management and analysis in Splunk & Kibana.	User login successful	{ "timestamp": "2023-05-08T14:35:10.123Z", "level": "INFO", "message": "User login successful", "userId": "12345", "ipAddress": "192.168.1.1" }