Author vs Contributor

[oca]

Author vs Contributor

[elicoidal]

I do not think there is a formal definition anywhere and I think your approach makes sense.
In general my vision on that is that the author "brings new ideas" while the contributor "fosters them"

[pedrobaeza]

When implementing the "idea" requires a total rebuilding of the module in a new version while migrating it, the developer deserves the authorship in my opinion, so I agree on all the points brought by @Tardo.

[elicoidal]

Agree: this is all very subjective on the level of work/originality of the contributor.

Question is today there is no formal definition of the concept (AFAIK). Is it necessary or letting the users decide case by case (my preferred way) is good enough?

Do we have often discussions on the topic?

[acysos]

Hello,

This is perfect, but like say @elicoidal, I don't see nothing formal. This is a great solution against people that they put as author for simple changes.

Greetings