trentbuck/binutils-is-llvm

Workaround https://lists.debian.org/debian-security/2019/12/msg00007.html by aliasing binutils to llvm

Status

As at 2021-04-07:

• binutils-is-llvm WORKS for needrestart -p (on Debian 11 bullseye).

  https://bugs.debian.org/986507 is an alternative.

• binutils-is-llvm DOES NOT WORK on for apt install build-essential, because that has a versioned dependency on binutils (>= X).

  To fix this, I would need to either make debian/changelog have corresponding version, or change my Provides: binutils to Provides: binutils (= X).

Problem

I want check-support-status to be happy, but I need needrestart:

bash5$ check-support-status
Limited security support for one or more packages

Unfortunately, it has been necessary to limit security support for some
packages.

The following packages found on this system are affected by this:

* Source:binutils
  Details: Only suitable for trusted content; see https://lists.debian.org/msgid-search/[email protected]
  Affected binary packages:
  - binutils (installed version: 2.35.2-2)
  - binutils-common:amd64 (installed version: 2.35.2-2)
  - binutils-x86-64-linux-gnu (installed version: 2.35.2-2)
  - libbinutils:amd64 (installed version: 2.35.2-2)
  - libctf-nobfd0:amd64 (installed version: 2.35.2-2)
  - libctf0:amd64 (installed version: 2.35.2-2)


bash5$ aptitude why binutils
i   needrestart Depends binutils

bash5$ sudo needrestart -p
CRIT - Kernel: 5.10.0-4-amd64!=5.10.0-5-amd64 (!!), Microcode: CURRENT, Services: 6 (!), Containers: none, Sessions: none|Kernel=2;0;;0;2 Microcode=0;0;;0;1 Services=6;;0;0 Containers=0;;0;0 Sessions=0;0;;0
Services:
- dbus.service
- [email protected]
- systemd-logind.service
- unattended-upgrades.service
- [email protected]
- [email protected]

Has anyone tried to solve this already?:

/connect irc.oftc.net
/join #debian-security
<twb> check-support-status (rightly) complains about binutils, but
      it's hard to avoid installing it.
      For example, both build-essential and needrestart need it.

      Is there a way to replace it with llvm (e.g. /usr/bin/strings ->  llvm-strings-10), so
      binutils can be purged, but without breaking anything?

<pabs> add an equivs package perhaps?

<twb> I'm thinking along those lines, yes.
      But I'm not sure how well the different implementation's arguments will line up.
      So it would need quite a bit of testing, and
      I was hoping someone else had already gotten annoyed enough to do it :-)