Ratified Version Document

[riscv]

Ratified Version Document

[Passer-Andes]

I saw a document with the tag v1.0.0, but the cover page of the source code still shows the version is 0.5.2-frozen.

[pdonahue-ventana]

@jjscheel: Is there anything that can be done about this? This extension is mandatory in RVA23 so the spec shouldn't be in this semi-abandoned pre-ratification state.

[jjscheel]

This information will be included in the main ISA manual soon and all references to the previous doc will be archived. So, an update for a version/title page seems not worth the time. Would you agree?

[jjscheel]

@wmat, can you confirm that Sscofpmf is in your Asciidoc chapters which will be built for the ISA manuals we're building? If so, would you kindly provide a link to the branch here so that we can close this out with complete information?

[wmat]

@jjscheel it will be in priv (after Svinval) but is not there yet.

[pdonahue-ventana]

That's fine if it is actually soon. One of the checklist items post-ratification should be to update things like this. That obviously wasn't the case in 2021 when this was ratified. This same problem also affects Sstc.

[jjscheel]

Good point, @pdonahue-ventana.

@rpsene, perhaps we can get a few sub-tasks in Jira for the following?

1. Updating the document to reflect "Ratified" state and building PDF.
2. Creating and submitting a final PR to riscv-isa-manual (for ISA and Fast Track only).
3. Publishing the Ratified document.

[rpsene]

@jjscheel we already have it; we can improve the description of the item. But we can also add a post-ratification task with this items.

[jjscheel]

No, that is the review item to make sure the repo is in a good state. It occurs BEFORE ratification.

@pdonahue-ventana, is talking about actions which must occur post ratification. They aren't really "Ecosystem Development", but rather completion of the Ratification work.